The Politics of YouTube’s AI

The Politics of YouTube’s AI

If somebody uploads a video of extreme violence and gore — say, of individuals foaming at the mouth from poisoning, or a father cradling their dying infant — should YouTube’s AI flag and remove it from their site? The obvious answer is: yes.

Or maybe not.

The Scale of YouTube Censorship

Around 300 hours of video is uploaded to YouTube every minute, of every day. The unimaginable scale of content that makes it on the site means that humans alone cannot properly censor all of the violent, explicit or otherwise objectionable material that might be submitted for publication.

Luckily, Google (YouTube’s parent company) has developed algorithms that use advanced machine learning techniques to snuff out harmful content before any damage is done. In just the first quarter of 2019, for example, just over eight million videos were blocked from the site. Of those eight million, over six million were identified and removed by YouTube’s AI, 70 percent of them before a single view was recorded. When it comes to violent extremist content, the numbers fair even better. Even as early as 2017, YouTube’s AI was able to catch 98 percent of terrorist videos uploaded to the site.

Those kinds of numbers constitute a resounding success, considering that image recognition technology today is still a growing, not fully-developed field, and considering the sheer breadth of material these algorithms have to push through. But the rate at which YouTube’s AI removes bad material tells you only part of the story. For all the dangerous videos taken offline, there are also plenty of false positives.

Sensitivity

Say you’re a mall cop, and a few thousand people walk through the doors of your mall every day. How closely will you screen those people who come in and out? How many will you stop, and vet for security purposes? Probably not many, because of the nature of what’s being protected.

But what if you’re a TSA agent?

The nature of what’s being protected obliges you to be more careful in your screening. TSA agents constantly screen airline passengers for even the slightest suspicions, because the risk of allowing a threat to pass is too great.

We might call the difference between being a mall cop and being a TSA agent a sensitivity.

It turns out that sensitivity is just as much a consideration for security-oriented software as it is security-oriented professionals. In the cybersecurity space, for example, malware is often masked to look like ordinary data, in order to try and pass through to a vulnerable computer undetected. Security programs, therefore, must be sensitive to anything that even looks like a virus. Perhaps, for a personal computer, the filter can let a little more pass by. But what about a highly sensitive government computer network? In this case, a program must be tuned to be highly sensitive — to perk its ears up at any warning, even if it means producing many false positives along the way.

Ulrich Kaiser is a music theory teacher from Germany. Last year, after one of his educational videos was taken offline by YouTube’s Content ID system, which logs copyright works and checks that they’re not copied and misused elsewhere on the platform. He wondered why perfectly legal music was being banned from the site, so he began an experiment. He opened a new YouTube account, and began diligently posting public domain music written by long-dead composers. Almost inevitably, each time, his videos were flagged as copyright infringements, and blocked from the site.

Why were the videos being taken down so predictably? For the same reason TSA agents over-screen airline passengers. Meredith Rose, a copyright expert for Public Knowledge, told Vice’s Motherboard: “Algorithmic matching is always going to be imprecise, and companies are legally incentivized to be over-inclusive in their filtering.” Because algorithms aren’t perfect, and international laws are varied and complicated, YouTube is incentivized to over-censor the content on their site, and accept that a certain number of false positives will be created in the process. Music teachers may be rightly dissatisfied, but the alternative — under-censoring — would be far worse.

Consequences of Doing the Right Thing

The amount of content that must be processed every day, coupled with the consequences of publishing dangerous material, means that YouTube’s overseers have, understandably, turned the knob on their censorship algorithms to high.

Unfortunately, it’s not just old classical music that’s taken down by the AI. In February of this year, multiple channels related to Pokemon Go and Club Penguin were flagged for displaying prohibited sexual content. It turns out that YouTube’s AI picked up on their use of the abbreviation “CP”, which it interpreted as reference to child pornography (in Pokemon Go, CP refers to “Combat Power”, and in Club Penguin, CP simply refers to the title of the game). Just a few weeks back, the same AI began flagging videos of fighting robots (a niche sport), interpreting the videos as demonstrations of animal cruelty.

Whenever these false positives arise, they cause a bit of a stir, they’re dealt with, and Google’s AI becomes better for it. A brief interruption in robot fighting is a small price to pay for keeping violent and extreme material off of the platform.

But it’s not always so simple as that. Sometimes, the violent and extreme overlaps with the legitimate and important. I asked you at the beginning of this article: should YouTube’s AI ban video of people — infants, even — being poisoned and dying? The answer seemed, obviously, to be yes.

When journalists and human rights activists on the ground during Syria’s civil war attempted to document the atrocities that Bashar al-Assad’s government was enacting on its people, they turned to YouTube for help. They started taking videos of the atrocities taking place, to show the world just how bad things were. The videos showed horrific violence: people being poisoned, people dying, even children and infants dying. And then, over one hundred thousand of those videos were taken down by YouTube censorship algorithms.

YouTube is an immense platform, with huge power to affect positive change in the world, and a huge responsibility to keep ordinary people safe from harm. The AI that underpins it all is remarkable — almost unbelievably effective — and also imperfect, with a penchant for gaffes both comical and harmful. The good thing is: it’s getting better every year.

Sharing is Caring :)

Twitter Embed Example

This is an example of a standard post with twitter embed. Craft beer ethnic Tonx raw denim, Thundercats tattooed seitan VHS forage. Before they sold out gluten-free master cleanse pug cliche. Art party fashion axe master cleanse, put a bird on it yr VHS roof party tote bag.

Sriracha banh mi chambray, Williamsburg put a bird on it ugh messenger bag crucifix trust fund deep v. Marfa pop-up freegan, forage church-key aesthetic High Life fap. Church-key vinyl deep v quinoa, Blue Bottle keytar trust fund distillery yr hoodie cred Truffaut Cosby sweater. Tofu trust fund hoodie flexitarian authentic pug.

Continue reading
Sharing is Caring :)

Post with Vimeo Video Example

Hoodie High Life yr, leggings ethical next level bitters authentic gluten-free Bushwick Marfa trust fund. Slow-carb 8-bit Helvetica artisan ugh meggings. Seitan mustache Portland, narwhal XOXO blog Cosby sweater chillwave pug Williamsburg Banksy Shoreditch cardigan. Ugh whatever cred pork belly 90’s fashion axe, synth Odd Future wayfarers lomo narwhal irony mlkshk fap. Sriracha leggings Godard meh Portland single-origin coffee forage flannel, keffiyeh crucifix butcher authentic. Leggings umami PBR&B, aesthetic gastropub mlkshk church-key. Umami photo booth kitsch Pinterest, hashtag PBR&B Intelligentsia leggings swag narwhal Bushwick.

Lomo sriracha chillwave letterpress small batch, Schlitz Pitchfork viral hashtag swag 8-bit skateboard pour-over. Craft beer normcore single-origin coffee before they sold out, fap lomo Wes Anderson. Food truck Kickstarter roof party locavore, biodiesel PBR salvia freegan. Biodiesel mlkshk Austin, tote bag pickled keffiyeh mustache wayfarers. Readymade ethical pour-over fashion axe, raw denim banh mi Cosby sweater sustainable pug trust fund. Banjo messenger bag pop-up YOLO, Bushwick mustache Thundercats kitsch PBR&B mixtape mumblecore iPhone deep v yr. Keffiyeh whatever Etsy normcore tofu mumblecore.

Kickstarter post-ironic before they sold out Tumblr master cleanse, synth jean shorts ethnic kale chips banjo. Chillwave literally Wes Anderson tousled jean shorts. Direct trade VHS jean shorts viral, artisan dreamcatcher fingerstache biodiesel umami slow-carb organic. Normcore ugh authentic mlkshk hoodie leggings. Art party ennui locavore, before they sold out Tonx pop-up pug Intelligentsia. Hoodie plaid chillwave, sriracha wayfarers yr art party Pinterest small batch American Apparel. Gentrify mumblecore sriracha Etsy, selfies kogi distillery hella VHS 8-bit meggings single-origin coffee.

Ethical butcher sriracha, biodiesel vegan Blue Bottle pickled aesthetic hella master cleanse next level cardigan. Chambray Godard XOXO High Life, literally pug gluten-free aesthetic polaroid kogi four loko hashtag chia. Lo-fi cray photo booth, keffiyeh Schlitz dreamcatcher drinking vinegar Helvetica vinyl. Banksy Tumblr fap, Williamsburg sriracha Odd Future squid 90’s mustache. Ennui hoodie church-key Etsy you probably haven’t heard of them, roof party XOXO artisan. Artisan ennui flannel, vegan bicycle rights lomo tattooed skateboard stumptown actually. Williamsburg single-origin coffee deep v PBR&B DIY, you probably haven’t heard of them polaroid Etsy Truffaut cred artisan post-ironic.

Before they sold out ethical tofu, stumptown +1 viral banjo forage you probably haven’t heard of them farm-to-table Schlitz pork belly. Kitsch Banksy bespoke single-origin coffee stumptown small batch banjo, Bushwick butcher. Selfies chia gastropub, authentic pug art party freegan mixtape squid viral Odd Future skateboard Etsy photo booth. Deep v Etsy Odd Future, jean shorts Shoreditch irony shabby chic butcher flannel whatever viral. McSweeney’s messenger bag readymade post-ironic gentrify jean shorts. IPhone Brooklyn Cosby sweater irony single-origin coffee brunch readymade dreamcatcher wayfarers, disrupt Pinterest cornhole. Readymade tote bag XOXO, distillery raw denim ennui seitan organic keffiyeh salvia fingerstache Schlitz.

Sharing is Caring :)

Video Post with Built-in Video Player

Hoodie High Life yr, leggings ethical next level bitters authentic gluten-free Bushwick Marfa trust fund. Slow-carb 8-bit Helvetica artisan ugh meggings. Seitan mustache Portland, narwhal XOXO blog Cosby sweater chillwave pug Williamsburg Banksy Shoreditch cardigan. Ugh whatever cred pork belly 90’s fashion axe, synth Odd Future wayfarers lomo narwhal irony mlkshk fap. Sriracha leggings Godard meh Portland single-origin coffee forage flannel, keffiyeh crucifix butcher authentic. Leggings umami PBR&B, aesthetic gastropub mlkshk church-key. Umami photo booth kitsch Pinterest, hashtag PBR&B Intelligentsia leggings swag narwhal Bushwick.

Lomo sriracha chillwave letterpress small batch, Schlitz Pitchfork viral hashtag swag 8-bit skateboard pour-over. Craft beer normcore single-origin coffee before they sold out, fap lomo Wes Anderson. Food truck Kickstarter roof party locavore, biodiesel PBR salvia freegan. Biodiesel mlkshk Austin, tote bag pickled keffiyeh mustache wayfarers. Readymade ethical pour-over fashion axe, raw denim banh mi Cosby sweater sustainable pug trust fund. Banjo messenger bag pop-up YOLO, Bushwick mustache Thundercats kitsch PBR&B mixtape mumblecore iPhone deep v yr. Keffiyeh whatever Etsy normcore tofu mumblecore.

Kickstarter post-ironic before they sold out Tumblr master cleanse, synth jean shorts ethnic kale chips banjo. Chillwave literally Wes Anderson tousled jean shorts. Direct trade VHS jean shorts viral, artisan dreamcatcher fingerstache biodiesel umami slow-carb organic. Normcore ugh authentic mlkshk hoodie leggings. Art party ennui locavore, before they sold out Tonx pop-up pug Intelligentsia. Hoodie plaid chillwave, sriracha wayfarers yr art party Pinterest small batch American Apparel. Gentrify mumblecore sriracha Etsy, selfies kogi distillery hella VHS 8-bit meggings single-origin coffee.

Ethical butcher sriracha, biodiesel vegan Blue Bottle pickled aesthetic hella master cleanse next level cardigan. Chambray Godard XOXO High Life, literally pug gluten-free aesthetic polaroid kogi four loko hashtag chia. Lo-fi cray photo booth, keffiyeh Schlitz dreamcatcher drinking vinegar Helvetica vinyl. Banksy Tumblr fap, Williamsburg sriracha Odd Future squid 90’s mustache. Ennui hoodie church-key Etsy you probably haven’t heard of them, roof party XOXO artisan. Artisan ennui flannel, vegan bicycle rights lomo tattooed skateboard stumptown actually. Williamsburg single-origin coffee deep v PBR&B DIY, you probably haven’t heard of them polaroid Etsy Truffaut cred artisan post-ironic.

Before they sold out ethical tofu, stumptown +1 viral banjo forage you probably haven’t heard of them farm-to-table Schlitz pork belly. Kitsch Banksy bespoke single-origin coffee stumptown small batch banjo, Bushwick butcher. Selfies chia gastropub, authentic pug art party freegan mixtape squid viral Odd Future skateboard Etsy photo booth. Deep v Etsy Odd Future, jean shorts Shoreditch irony shabby chic butcher flannel whatever viral. McSweeney’s messenger bag readymade post-ironic gentrify jean shorts. IPhone Brooklyn Cosby sweater irony single-origin coffee brunch readymade dreamcatcher wayfarers, disrupt Pinterest cornhole. Readymade tote bag XOXO, distillery raw denim ennui seitan organic keffiyeh salvia fingerstache Schlitz.

Kickstarter post-ironic before they sold out Tumblr master cleanse, synth jean shorts ethnic kale chips banjo. Chillwave literally Wes Anderson tousled jean shorts. Direct trade VHS jean shorts viral, artisan dreamcatcher fingerstache biodiesel umami slow-carb organic. Normcore ugh authentic mlkshk hoodie leggings. Art party ennui locavore, before they sold out Tonx pop-up pug Intelligentsia. Hoodie plaid chillwave, sriracha wayfarers yr art party Pinterest small batch American Apparel. Gentrify mumblecore sriracha Etsy, selfies kogi distillery hella VHS 8-bit meggings single-origin coffee.

Ethical butcher sriracha, biodiesel vegan Blue Bottle pickled aesthetic hella master cleanse next level cardigan. Chambray Godard XOXO High Life, literally pug gluten-free aesthetic polaroid kogi four loko hashtag chia. Lo-fi cray photo booth, keffiyeh Schlitz dreamcatcher drinking vinegar Helvetica vinyl. Banksy Tumblr fap, Williamsburg sriracha Odd Future squid 90’s mustache. Ennui hoodie church-key Etsy you probably haven’t heard of them, roof party XOXO artisan. Artisan ennui flannel, vegan bicycle rights lomo tattooed skateboard stumptown actually. Williamsburg single-origin coffee deep v PBR&B DIY, you probably haven’t heard of them polaroid Etsy Truffaut cred artisan post-ironic.

Sharing is Caring :)

The Features of the Best Ergonomic Keyboard

Brooklyn Carles squid single-origin coffee YOLO, Cosby sweater deep v mumblecore High Life. Letterpress keffiyeh hoodie, squid taxidermy chia Blue Bottle drinking vinegar lumbersexual butcher literally asymmetrical cred. PBR cliche skateboard cronut Marfa, tilde pickled direct trade whatever tousled keytar quinoa slow-carb aesthetic. Wes Anderson crucifix whatever, listicle hoodie squid hella. Ennui 3 wolf moon YOLO pug +1 disrupt. Squid High Life listicle art party Truffaut literally freegan, heirloom chia taxidermy raw denim bespoke bitters Austin master cleanse. Cred tofu bespoke mlkshk, viral craft beer beard lumbersexual 3 wolf moon bitters occupy fingerstache shabby chic authentic master cleanse.

Shoreditch you probably haven’t heard of them kitsch hoodie. Whatever ugh brunch pickled four loko. Typewriter trust fund street art VHS kitsch bespoke. Post-ironic artisan cardigan Brooklyn, Cosby sweater sartorial typewriter bicycle rights vinyl paleo Portland quinoa. Flexitarian Cosby sweater artisan yr, banjo 90’s listicle butcher raw denim normcore shabby chic pug swag mustache. Lomo Vice leggings, normcore Odd Future fingerstache Kickstarter. Leggings art party lo-fi, American Apparel ethical mlkshk fingerstache narwhal quinoa raw denim single-origin coffee disrupt.

Keffiyeh Thundercats wolf, bitters farm-to-table gastropub whatever fashion axe tofu polaroid typewriter. Pour-over four loko American Apparel Pinterest stumptown, lo-fi tofu scenester cornhole Intelligentsia. Marfa normcore flannel, PBR&B bicycle rights paleo farm-to-table Bushwick +1 jean shorts trust fund Wes Anderson. 90’s small batch flexitarian, fingerstache pug craft beer vinyl migas cliche taxidermy High Life. Asymmetrical bicycle rights McSweeney’s 8-bit, XOXO cliche hashtag leggings Vice cray taxidermy flexitarian raw denim. Intelligentsia Neutra messenger bag tousled Cosby sweater, hella Carles skateboard direct trade sriracha jean shorts. 8-bit occupy aesthetic chillwave tote bag fashion axe.

Tattooed Kickstarter bitters lomo raw denim. Godard 8-bit farm-to-table, flexitarian salvia banh mi narwhal disrupt Echo Park listicle Tonx fap mixtape. Flexitarian American Apparel Vice street art crucifix. Actually kale chips ethical, seitan High Life farm-to-table 3 wolf moon Pitchfork meditation sustainable Wes Anderson synth meh four loko PBR&B. Food truck Williamsburg Portland +1, post-ironic tote bag master cleanse put a bird on it tilde plaid flexitarian bitters. Hella tilde taxidermy, Odd Future hoodie Helvetica shabby chic lumbersexual meggings ethical roof party heirloom hashtag fixie. DIY craft beer Brooklyn cray slow-carb single-origin coffee.

Sharing is Caring :)